Stock, Broth, and Soup Season!
posted on
November 17, 2026

About two years ago I posted a blog spot titled, “Eating with the Seasons: Nourishing Stock” (October 22, 2024). In it I outlined my practice of starting a pot of stock with the first frost.
Nourishing Traditions by Sally Fallon and Mary Enig was the reference source for information and recipes.
For this article I consulted Nourishing Broth by Sally Fallon and Kaayla Daniel, an in-depth discussion of research and recipes. Every year when I initiate my batch of stock, I try a different soup recipe from this book. Over the years I’ve identified a few favorites, but I’m always seeking more variety.
If you’ve made bone stock and have had difficulty getting it to gel, here are a few possible reasons for your troubles, and some solutions.
| Problem | Solution | |
|---|---|---|
| Incorrect Kind of Bones | Use 1/3 marrow bones, 1/3 meaty bones, and 1/3 kunckle bones | |
| Not Enough Bones/Too Much Water | Correct proportion for chickens: 3-4 lbs. bones per gallon of water; for beef: 7 lbs. bones per gallon. | |
| Temperature Too High | Heat over medium heat until it starts to roll, then immediately turn heat down to low until barely simmering. | |
| Cooking Too Long/Not Cooking Long Enough | Simmer Chicken Bones 4-6 hours; Beef Bones for a full day, or overnight. |
Gelatin forms from the breakdown of collagen by heating various types of tissues such as skin, sinews, cartilage, tendons, and ligaments. There are about 29 types collagen in animal tissues. They are found in skin, tendons, ligaments, internal organs, bones, cell membranes, blood vessels, eyes, hair, teeth, nails, and placenta. It is involved in biological processes including protecting joints and skin, elasticity of tendons and ligaments, bones and muscles. It plays important roles in healthy aging, healing of various kinds of injuries, prevention and treatment of autoimmune disorders (e.g., rheumatoid arthritis, Crohn’s disease), muscular dystrophy, diabetes, and cancer.
The recommendation for general wellness and health maintenance is one cup of stock or broth per day. Use it to make soups, sauces and gravies.
If you are dealing with a particular health issue, then three cups of broth or stock per day is recommended — one in the morning, one at mid day, and one in the evening.
May you be deeply nourished.
***********
If you’re interested in a deeper dive into the healing power of bone stock and broth, explore the work of the scientists featured in Nourishing Broth. Here are just a few:
Nathan R. Gotthoffer, PhD
John F. Prudden, MD
Milan Adam, DSci
James M. Rippe, MD
Kristine L. Clark, PhD, RD
Roland Moskowitz, MD
