Buffalo Chicken Sweet Potatoes??

written by

Melissa Barth

posted on

May 26, 2025

Earlier this year, I had an amazing dinner at my weekly Bible fellowship gathering. 

It was a concept that I had seen before but never made because, quite honestly, it seemed a little too “out there”. The fact that I replicated that dinner only two days later says that (at least in my book) this meal was a winner.  

May I introduce: buffalo chicken stuffed sweet potatoes!  

There are many recipes online for this, but I am going to tell you how I made it.  

First, I roasted a whole chicken in the oven and deboned and shredded it. (Easy method: put a whole chicken - breast side down - into my Dutch oven, season well with salt and pepper, put the lid on, and bake at 300 degrees until internal temperature reaches 165+. For frozen or partially frozen chickens, this is approximately 3 hours. For completely thawed chicken, 1.5-2 hours.) 

Next, I baked some sweet potatoes. (See note below)

Then, I made some homemade ranch dressing (you can find recipes online for this) 

After that, I mixed together  

- 9 Tbsp of my favorite hot sauce 

- 3 Tbsp of mayonnaise (We prefer homemade mayonnaise)  

- 1 Tbsp of homemade ranch dressing 

- 1/2 tsp of garlic powder 

- 1/2 tsp of salt 

I then poured half the sauce over half of the shredded chicken, adding either more chicken or sauce until I got the proportion of meat to sauce that I wanted. This ratio is a personal preference! 

I then chopped some green onions and put the chicken/sauce mixture on the stove to warm. 

Now for the fun part….  

Once the sweet potatoes were done, I cut them open and generously topped them with the warm buffalo chicken. 

This recipe would not be complete without sprinkling generous amounts of blue cheese crumbles and green onions over top of the potatoes and drizzling them with extra homemade ranch.  

This recipe also works well with russet potatoes. I personally liked the sweet potatoes. 

If you don’t like blue cheese, feta is a good substitute. However, I recommend trying it with blue cheese first so that you can impress yourself with your adventurousness.  

This meal is great because you can stage it at your convenience and keep it warm until you are ready to eat!  

NOTE: For easy, fast "baked" sweet potatoes, wash and prick whole sweet potatoes with a fork. Place them into an instant pot (or other pressure cooker) with ½ cup water. (I like to use my steamer tray to keep the potatoes off the bottom of the pot, but it's not necessary.) Set the pressure setting to HIGH and cook, sealed, for 11 minutes. Quick release the pressure once done.  

Happy eating! 

Melissa

More from the blog

VIRTUAL TOUR: Egg-laying Chickens

I absolutely love walking the fields at Polyface and seeing the animals living out their natural uniqueness. For over a decade now, one of my favorite yearly rituals has been taking spring walks there—pausing just to listen to the quiet, steady sound of cows grazing. There’s something incredibly grounding about it. I also get a kick out of watching the chickens dart and weave, especially when one finds an earthworm and suddenly turns into a tiny, determined guardian of her prize. And the pigs! ...They’re endlessly entertaining. I could stand there forever just breathing it all in and laughing at how curious and playful they are as they explore their space. I really think everyone should visit Polyface at least once. Seeing it in person makes such a powerful impression. It’s completely different from what most people picture when they think of a typical American farm. That said, I know not everyone gets the chance to go. So I’m especially grateful for the folks who film and share these experiences, making it possible to get a glimpse of that beauty and peace from afar. Take a break and check out this virtual tour of their egg-laying chickens. Blessings, Hannah

Forage Diversity

What's the common denominators for the most balanced and heaviest load of nutrients in beef? Breed? Climate? Age? Joel breaks it down.